Here Are The Best Ways To Sell Your Baseball Card Collection

Are you looking to get into the baseball card-selling business? It can be a fun process, but also overwhelming at times. Whether you’re downsizing your collection or looking to trade cards for new additions, navigating the selling landscape requires careful planning and consideration.

From choosing which platforms to sell your cards on to packaging cards securely for shipping, there are many steps to undertake in the process of selling some of your collection.

To help make your life easier, HobbyListings has created an extensive guide to help you successfully sell your baseball cards.

sports cards
(credit: Mick Haupt/Unsplash)

Choosing the Best-Selling Platforms

eBay homepage
(credit: Oberon Copeland
  1. eBay: Known for its vast audience and auction-style listings, eBay offers a broad reach for selling baseball cards. Create detailed listings with clear images and descriptions to attract potential buyers.
  2. COMC (Check Out My Cards): This platform allows you to consign your cards, managing the selling process while they handle storage, listing, and shipping. It provides a hassle-free selling experience.
  3. Auction Houses: For high-value or rare cards, consider auction houses like Goldin Auctions or Heritage Auctions. They specialize in sports memorabilia auctions and attract serious collectors.
  4. Social Media Platforms: Using Facebook, X (formerly known as Twitter) or online forums, you can connect directly with enthusiasts interested in purchasing cards. Ensure you comply with group rules when selling and also make sure when you’re selling cards to use the Goods and Services option on PayPal and Venmo.
  5. Local Card Shops or Collectibles Shows: Selling directly to local card shops or participating in collectibles shows can provide immediate sales opportunities and allow for face-to-face interactions with buyers.

Strategies for Selling

(Photo by Alexander Mils on Unsplash)
  1. Research and Pricing: Conduct thorough research to determine the value of your cards. Consider factors like condition, rarity, and current market trends to set competitive prices.
  2. Quality Images and Descriptions: Take clear, high-resolution images of your cards and provide detailed, accurate descriptions including card condition, year, brand, and any notable features.
  3. Bundle and Lots: Grouping cards into lots or themed bundles can attract buyers looking for specific sets or players, making the selling process more efficient.
  4. Auctions vs. Fixed Prices: Decide between auction-style listings or fixed-price formats based on your preference and the demand for your cards. Auctions can create excitement and potentially drive up prices, while fixed prices offer stability.

Packaging Cards for Shipping

bubble wrap
(Photo by Kier in Sight Archives on Unsplash)
  1. Sleeves and Toploaders: Place individual cards in penny sleeves to protect them from scratches, then slide them into toploaders for added rigidity and further protection.
  2. Team Bags or Card Savers: Group multiple cards together in team bags or card savers, securing them prevent movement during transit.
  3. Card Boxes or Bubble Mailers: Use cardboard card boxes or padded bubble mailers to house the sleeved and toploaded cards. Ensure they fit snugly to prevent shifting.
  4. Sturdy Packaging Materials: Fill any empty spaces in the shipping container with packing peanuts, bubble wrap, or crumpled paper to prevent the cards from moving within the box or mailer.
  5. Labeling and Sealing: Clearly label the package with the recipient’s address and your return address. Seal the package securely with strong packing tape to prevent any tampering or damage during transit.

Shipping and Handling Considerations

shipping box
(Photo by RoseBox رز باکس on Unsplash)
  1. Insured Shipping: Consider using shipping methods that offer insurance for valuable cards to safeguard against loss or damage during transit.
  2. Tracking and Delivery Confirmation: Always opt for shipping services that provide tracking and delivery confirmation. This allows both you and the buyer to monitor the package’s progress.
  3. Communication with Buyers: Keep buyers informed about the shipping process, provide tracking information promptly, and be responsive to any inquiries they may have.
  4. Feedback and Reviews: Encourage buyers to leave feedback or reviews upon receiving their purchase. Positive reviews can enhance your credibility as a seller for future transactions.

Selling your baseball card collection involves a blend of preparation, research, and attention to detail. By leveraging the correct platforms, employing effective selling strategies, and ensuring secure packaging and shipping, you can streamline the selling process while maximizing your returns.

Top Auction Houses

1952 Topps Mickey Mantle
1952 Topps Mickey Mantle. (credit: Heritage Auctions)

If you have extremely rare or valuable baseball cards, going the auction house-route might be the best way to sell. They have connections to top bidders who will pay big bucks to add to their collection. Here’s a list of the top auction houses to potentially do business with.

Heritage Auctions

Specialty: Heritage Auctions is a leading auction house known for its expertise in sports memorabilia, including baseball cards. They host regular auctions featuring an extensive range of cards, from vintage classics to modern-day rarities.

Advantages: Their vast clientele, extensive marketing, and online presence attract a global audience of collectors. Heritage Auctions’ professionalism, detailed listings, and transparency in the auction process make them a top choice for sellers.

Process: Sellers can consign their cards to Heritage Auctions, where their team of experts appraises, catalogs, and promotes the items for auction. They offer both live and online auctions, providing flexibility in reaching potential buyers.

SCP Auctions

Specialty: SCP Auctions specializes in high-end sports memorabilia, including valuable baseball cards. They have a track record of handling significant collections and rare cards, drawing serious collectors and investors.

Advantages: SCP Auctions’ reputation for handling prestigious collections and their personalized approach to consignors make them a preferred choice for sellers seeking individual attention and guidance.

Process: Consignors can submit their cards for evaluation by SCP Auctions’ experts, who then assess the items’ value and market potential. SCP Auctions conducts online auctions, often featuring exclusive and noteworthy baseball card collections.

Goldin Auctions

Specialty: Goldin Auctions is renowned for handling high-value sports collectibles, including a wide array of baseball cards. They frequently feature rare and iconic cards in their auctions, appealing to serious collectors.

Advantages: Goldin Auctions’ emphasis on high-value items, their marketing prowess, and their ability to attract celebrity consignments make them a sought-after platform for selling premium baseball cards.

Process: Sellers can consign their cards to Goldin Auctions, where their team evaluates and promotes the items for auction. They conduct both live and online auctions, showcasing a diverse selection of baseball cards.


Specialty: Lelands is known for its long-standing history in sports memorabilia auctions, offering a platform for selling a range of collectibles, including valuable baseball cards.

Advantages: With their legacy and expertise in the industry, Lelands has established a loyal collector base. They often handle unique and historically significant items, attracting enthusiasts and serious buyers.

Process: Consignors can submit their cards to Lelands for appraisal, where their experts assess the items’ value and market potential. Lelands conducts regular auctions, providing opportunities to sell baseball cards to a dedicated audience.

Memory Lane Inc.

Specialty: Memory Lane Inc. specializes in sports memorabilia auctions, including a strong focus on baseball cards. They handle a wide range of vintage and high-value cards, appealing to serious collectors and investors.

Advantages: Known for their expertise in handling rare and iconic cards, Memory Lane Inc. offers personalized service and extensive marketing, attracting a dedicated audience of collectors.

Process: Consignors can submit their cards for evaluation by Memory Lane Inc.’s experts, who assess the items’ value and authenticity. Their auctions feature both graded and ungraded cards, providing options for various collections.

Huggins & Scott Auctions

Specialty: Huggins & Scott Auctions conduct regular sports memorabilia auctions, showcasing a selection of baseball cards, including vintage and modern collectibles.

Advantages: With a focus on sports collectibles, Huggins & Scott Auctions offer consignors a platform to sell baseball cards alongside other sports-related items, attracting a diverse audience of collectors.

Process: Sellers can consign their cards to Huggins & Scott Auctions, where their team appraises and lists the items for auction. They conduct both online and live auctions, providing opportunities for sellers to reach interested buyers.

Robert Edward Auctions (REA)

Specialty: Robert Edward Auctions (REA) is known for its specialized auctions featuring rare and historic sports memorabilia, including a significant selection of vintage baseball cards.

Advantages: REA’s reputation for handling prestigious collections, their meticulous cataloging process, and their focus on rare and unique cards make them a preferred choice for serious collectors and investors.

Process: Consignors can submit their baseball cards to REA for evaluation, where their experts assess the items’ condition and market value. REA conducts comprehensive auctions, often featuring iconic and museum-quality cards.

Mile High Card Company

Specialty: Mile High Card Company specializes in high-grade and rare sports cards, including a notable selection of vintage and modern baseball cards.

Advantages: Known for their emphasis on high-quality items, Mile High Card Company attracts collectors seeking premium-grade cards and provides a platform for consignors to sell sought-after baseball cards.

Process: Sellers can consign their cards to Mile High Card Company for evaluation and listing in their auctions. They conduct regular auctions, featuring graded and ungraded cards from various eras of baseball history.

These auction houses broaden the options available for sellers looking to consign their baseball card collections. Each auction house offers its unique approach, audience, and expertise in handling valuable and sought-after cards. Consider factors such as their specialization, track record, commission rates, and auction formats before choosing the right platform to sell your prized baseball card collection. Engaging with reputable auction houses ensures a professional and successful selling experience for collectors aiming to maximize the value of their cards.

Matt Higgins contributed to this report.

Leave a Reply